Blog

What Tech Can and Can’t Do To Fight Unemployment

Monday, October 17th, 2011

I’m doing a forum this Wednesday in New York on “The Real Cost of Unemployment” — it’s free and open to the public as long as you reserve tickets.

The forum is as much about the future of employment in America as it is unemployment in the right here and now. When it comes to unemployment, we’re facing a precipice where continued unemployment will drive more families into a spiral of debt; loss of homes; and diminishment of educational opportunities as property taxes fall. And then there’s the question of what will happen to people told that they could go to college and find steady, even fulfilling employment as a result; but who can find jobs every now and then, not careers.

So, as an alternative to bemoaning our fate and handwringing over the end of life as we know it, plenty of us are trying to figure out what will work to re-employ those who’ve slipped through the cracks (blue and white collar) and create new opportunities for the people graduating into a harsh job market.

For years, technology has been touted as a path to reviving the economy. Yet a recent piece in the Economist gave this little reality check: “Apple, Google, Facebook and Amazon collectively employ just 113,000 people, a third of GM’s payroll in 1980.” The article adds:

Americans’ entrepreneurial self-esteem is now embodied by Apple, Google, Facebook and Amazon. These are indeed fabulously innovative companies with world-beating business models. Yet one wonders if they are increasingly the exception, not the rule, and if the passing of Mr Jobs is simply the most prominent example of a broader decline in American entrepreneurship. According to JPMorgan, in the late 1990s, employment at start-up companies regularly grew 1.2m per quarter. That has fallen to 700,000 since the current recovery began. John Haltiwanger, probably the leading economist on employment dynamics by firm size, finds similar trends. Entrepreneurship and innovation, of course, are not the same thing. Yet even if American innovation is fundamentally sound, there remains the more unsettling problem of how narrowly its fruits are shared.

There are a many different ways that technology can employ more people. One is the tech/manufacturing sector. An August New York Times article profiled a lithium ion battery factory in Michigan. As it examined this one company, it weighed tech and manufacturing, and said the future of tech-driven jobs could be one that “looks less like Google and more like Ford.” Writer John Gertner added:

One challenge to moving in this direction may be that our banks, hedge funds and venture capitalists are geared toward investing in financial instruments and software companies. In such endeavors, even modest investments can yield extraordinarily quick and large returns. Financing brick-and-mortar factories, by contrast, is expensive and painstaking and offers far less potential for speedy returns. Berger maintains that for the economy to get “full value” from our laboratories’ ideas in energy or biotech — not just new company headquarters but industrial jobs too — we must aspire to a different business model than the one we have come to admire.

A completely different way that tech is helping to solve the unemployment crisis is through crowd funding. Companies like Kickstarter (profiled here) and Indie Go Go are helping to fund a remarkably heterogeneous array of projects, from movies to housewares to toys. The Kickstarter model has been discussed at length. One question circling back to jobs is whether this could help create a cohort of people who, in what we once considered a normal job market, would work and maybe do projects on the side, but who instead choose a path of serial small-scale entrepreneurship enabled by crowd funding. Whether or not crowd funding can achieve a critical mass nationally will bear some longitudinal study of how people use it. A major factor will be whether the model expands in adoption beyond people who are tech early-adopters and risk-tolerant to people who might use some crowd funding engine (perhaps one not even in existence) to restructure their work lives entirely.

As these long-plays for a revived job market are being worked out, we’re looking for shorter term solutions. That’s one reason we’re hosting the forum. It’s time to put our collective brainpower together and see what we can make out of the job market, not just wait for anyone else to come up with solutions.

========

The forum “The Real Cost of Unemployment” starts with a reception at 6 and a program at 7. Our guests include investor Ryan Mack, personal finance commentator (Today Show, CNN) and author of “The Real Cost of Living” Carmen Wong Ulrich; and Columbia University Professor Dorian Ward, who studies labor markets. Join us if you’re in NYC.

You can also join the Public Insight Network, a group of individuals who offer their perspectives to public radio, by participating in our survey on the impact of unemployment on your friends, family, community, and perhaps yourself. Go to the survey here.

Thanks so much!

Wounded But Still Standing: America in An Age of High Anxiety

Tuesday, September 21st, 2010

Producer Suzie Lechtenberg interviewing Gainesville residents at interfaith forum

Producer Suzie Lechtenberg at Gainesville, FL, interfaith forum

Traveling through America as I have been for our elections project, I cannot help but look at America in military metaphors, as a soldier who has served a tour of duty and, even amid a momentary respite, cannot help but wonder if rotations to the field will continue indefinitely. The battles are economic, on one level. Jobs and the economy remain the top issues. Neighborhoods rocked by foreclosures are sometimes finding a new equilibrium– even if that equilibrium means learning to live with one or two abandoned houses on a once-full block. America has survived the dizzying economic crash of 2008, but we remain ready to fight for an American Dream that sometimes we can’t even define.

This fall I’ve been able to realize a dream of my own, to put together a team of multimedia journalists to go out and explore America in a time of heavy hearts and stifled aspirations. The project is housed at and shepherded by WNYC with help from American Public Media. Our Pop and Politics midterm election specials will air in October and November, but we are doing the reporting now. Having gone out in Florida, we’re preparing to head to Arizona next.

Florida was full-on. We got to LaGuardia airport in New York at four AM and before 11am we were on the ground in Miami, interviewing the head of Take Back the Land, an organization that places families without homes in abandoned homes. Of course, they do so without the permission of authorities, banks, or many other people. As Max Rameau of TBTL outlined it, the one group of people they did consult was neighbors, many of whom would rather have a formerly homeless family on their block than a place that got broken into or stripped.

We spoke with people whose lives were various refractions of the housing crisis… Ruby, who poured her retirement savings into fixing a home she may lose to foreclosure; and Peter Zalewski, who left the world of business journalism to mine profits from the housing crisis. Now he buys up to 700 “distressed units” at a time, and sells them to buyers at a cost above what he paid the banks, but below market. Among the memorable things he said was that he would love to open the borders wide… that the more non-Americans we had coming in, the better, because they were buying the homes Americans could no longer afford.

Our journeys took us to Gainesville, a college town where a threatened Koran burning turned into a media circus with an upside… an interfaith gathering that brought together people of many backgrounds. We also got to visit Tallevast, a small black town dying a slow death from toxins leached from a plant. Cassandra, below, has given us her perspective as the unofficial town historian.
Cassandra in Tallevast, Florida

Some of this material is here on our website already, but all of it will be on our radio shows. It’s hard to run full tilt doing the reporting and to process it at the same time — to process it for broadcast or process it emotionally. This country is in deep, deep cotton. But the people we meet have spirit and heart.

And then after Florida our team returned to New York, and were swept back into the alternate reality of this massive city. New York has certain advantages in this time of need. Because the city is so dense and housing is so scarce, there are fewer abandoned properties than there might be in other cities experiencing the turbulence. It’s not to say New York isn’t hurting, just that the way we are hurting is the way we live: tough, smart, and wise to the game. As I walked through the tony TriBeCa neighborhood in New York, past the actor Harvey Keitel, I took note of the number of empty stores and offices… huge ones. Six thousand square feet! crowed one banner ad across a grimy glass window. (In New York, a single or couple might well live in a place closer to six hundred square feet.)

The trickle-down anxiety of our historical moment affects everything, from how and where we live to our worship and our very life and breath. I look forward to sharing more soon.

Got Stories? “The Value: What Matters More than Money”

Wednesday, December 16th, 2009

I’ve been experimenting with a new multimedia reporting/profile series called “The Value.” It airs both on public radio via WNYC’s syndicated show The Takeaway, and online at http://www.thetakeaway.org.

The idea is to ask: what’s worth more than money? In some cases, like Anna Deavere Smith, it’s mastery of craft and storytelling. In others, it’s adventure (in Antarctica!); service to people who’ve survived the civil war in Sri Lanka; or creating an urban oasis.

I’m limited by the fact that there is no travel budget, so the series has to be where I am: mainly NY, but also, in the coming weeks, DC, Baltimore, Miami, Northern and Southern California, and St. Louis.

I would LOVE suggestions for stories. Email me via the “contact” link on the top right of this website.

Here are the first four episodes of The Value.